September 15, 2025
The district’s elementary academics ‘went via the supplies searching for issues which may be controversial, mentioned Superintendent Joe Craig. They didn’t really feel these elements of the curriculum ‘have been in step with what we wished the lesson to give attention to.’
This coming college 12 months, the Fairfield, Texas, college district, about midway between Dallas and Houston, will roll out a new Ok-5 studying program that features a number of references to the bible, The 74 studies.
However the workers, hoping to keep away from debates over households’ non secular beliefs, has chopped roughly 30 sections out of the curriculum, together with a kindergarten lesson on the Golden Rule that includes Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount and several other bible excerpts a few Christian prayer the governor of Plymouth Colony mentioned on the first Thanksgiving.
The district’s elementary academics “went via the supplies searching for issues which may be controversial,” mentioned Superintendent Joe Craig. They didn’t really feel these elements of the curriculum “have been in step with what we wished the lesson to give attention to.”
Fairfield’s course of displays the type of selective method that many districts have taken towards Bluebonnet Studying—the state-developed supplies that prominently function the Bible and Christianity. With suggestions from 300 academics, Fort Value, the fifth largest district within the state, adopted the phonics portion of the curriculum, however turned down the models with non secular materials. Some districts ordered just some books, probably for evaluate functions, whereas the Houston and Dallas districts opted to maintain what they at the moment use.
Texas has spent roughly $100 million—and counting—to develop and promote its personal studying curriculum. However some observers say they wouldn’t be shocked if districts aren’t dashing to select it up, contemplating the State Board of Schooling authorised it by a one-vote margin.
“They could be reluctant to convey that very same controversy into their districts, particularly in communities with households of numerous non secular backgrounds,” mentioned Eve Myers, a advisor with Try Public Coverage Assets, a political consulting and lobbying agency that’s monitoring adoption of this system. “It’s probably a distraction from their give attention to the price range, scholar achievement, college security, and all the opposite urgent points they have to tackle.”
Texas has over 1,200 districts and about 600 constitution colleges with elementary grades. Of the state’s 20 largest districts, solely Conroe, north of Houston, intends to make use of the bible program this fall. A state buying system exhibits that between Might and late July, 144 districts and charters, largely mid-sized or small, ordered the supplies.
State board members have requested for the entire variety of districts utilizing Bluebonnet. “That’s the query we’d all prefer to know,” mentioned Pam Little, a board member who voted in opposition to the studying program final November.
Different districts may very well be utilizing the web model of the supplies, however whether or not college students would have precise books and spend much less time on screens was a significant debate final 12 months in the course of the board’s consideration of this system.
State leaders and conservative advocates say the non secular content material displays a classical and applicable approach to educate literacy expertise together with historical past and tradition. Others just like the emphasis on cursive writing and difficult vocabulary. In an interview with The 74 final 12 months, State Commissioner of Schooling Mike Morath mentioned a phonics-based curriculum that additionally builds college students’ background information will help the state get well from declines in studying expertise because of the pandemic.
However this system sparked a statewide debate over whether or not political leaders are forcing Christianity into public colleges. Bluebonnet makes its debut within the classroom on the similar time colleges can be required, underneath a brand new state legislation, to show the 10 Commandments from the bible. Gov. Greg Abbott additionally signed laws in June that enables districts to supply a each day, voluntary time frame to hope and browse the Bible or different non secular texts. Underneath the same 2023 legislation, districts can rent chaplains to volunteer as counselors, however most districts aren’t collaborating.
“There’s positively a disconnect between the novel far proper agenda…and what college boards who’re accountable to native households and college students are literally going to do,” mentioned Guthrie Graves-Fitzsimmons, senior director of coverage and advocacy on the Interfaith Alliance, a nationwide group that advocates for church-state separation. Texas, he mentioned, is “taking away the rights of clergy and fogeys to guide non secular instruction.”
Within the 73,000-student Conroe college district, Dayren Carlisle, a curriculum director, mentioned leaders picked Bluebonnet as a result of academics have been beforehand working with a patchwork of supplies. They usually spent “arduous hours getting ready for studying and writing instruction,” she informed The 74 in an e mail. Bluebonnet offers a coherent set of classes that meet state requirements, she mentioned.
However mother or father Christine Yates advocated in opposition to it.
“I don’t suppose religious-based instruction belongs in any sort of public college setting,” mentioned Yates, whose youngsters can be in second and fourth grade this fall. Her household doesn’t attend church, and she or he’s involved that the teachings coping with religion are simply “borrowing hassle.”
Becky Sherrill, a former Conroe trainer, sympathizes with educators who should navigate dad and mom’ requests to decide their youngsters out of the teachings. It’s a proper that many dad and mom is likely to be extra more likely to train this fall due to a June U.S. Supreme Courtroom opinion in favor of spiritual households who need their youngsters exempted from listening to tales with LGBTQ themes.
“It’s arduous on the trainer. It’s already so arduous at Christmas and even with birthdays,” Sherrill mentioned, referring to Jehovah’s Witnesses she has had as college students. “You possibly can’t give some youngsters cupcakes as a result of they don’t have fun birthdays.”
She’s already homeschooling her center college son and has pulled her daughter, a fifth grader, out of the district as effectively, largely due to Bluebonnet and the ten Commandments legislation.
At a Might board assembly, Carlisle defined to the board how academics will area requests from dad and mom who wish to decide their youngsters out of the teachings from the bible.
“If a mother or father have been to complain about this … we must discover a fully completely different textual content,” she mentioned.
However that didn’t sit effectively with Tiffany Baumann Nelson, one among three conservative college board members, who name themselves Mama Bears, elected in 2022.
“There isn’t any faith on this curriculum,” she argued. “They’re all historic references, and so for my part, there must be no different or modifications.”
Whether or not districts are eradicating biblical materials or dad and mom are opting their youngsters out of the bible classes, Little, the state board member, worries that college students may miss literacy expertise they’re speculated to study.
“Say an East Asian non secular mother or father has determined they don’t need their youngster to have [a Bible story]. Is that youngster going to overlook ability improvement?” she requested. Accommodating dad and mom’ requests will even be a burden on district workers. “What’s the price concerned within the manpower time for these districts to undergo and eradicate the non secular content material? There was no want for the controversy that the non secular content material goes to start out.”
The state board narrowly authorised the brand new program final fall after the Texas Schooling Company spent roughly $84 million to adapt an current studying curriculum from the corporate Amplify. Renamed Bluebonnet, after the state flower, the Texas model contains highlights of Jesus’ ministry and gives an evangelical view of early American historical past. Classes, for instance, embrace the parable of the Prodigal Son, an artwork historical past unit based mostly on the creation story from Genesis, and scriptural references to the motto on the Liberty Bell.
The company, which might not present an inventory of all districts which have ordered this system, paid a number of corporations and content material specialists to craft and evaluate the teachings, together with the far-right Texas Public Coverage Basis. Hillsdale Faculty, a Christian college in Michigan, volunteered to work on models associated to America’s founding, and a Christian media firm, co-founded by Mike Huckabee, U.S. ambassador to Israel, contributed illustrations. However Texas officers refused to determine who wrote the biblical passages.
In response to backlash, officers added extra references to Islam and Hinduism and eliminated some texts that have been offensive to Jews, however the last model nonetheless references Christianity greater than different religions.
“We reviewed it and cherished it,” mentioned Cindi Castilla, president of the Texas Eagle Discussion board, a conservative group. She pushed for state board approval of the curriculum final 12 months, saying that there’s “richness in biblical literature” and that Bible tales educate youngsters character traits and the origins of the authorized system.
Since then, she examined the ultimate model with retired educators who’ve expertise instructing a classical curriculum and suppose it is going to strengthen college students’ cursive and phonics expertise. That’s why Gina Eubank needs her grandchildren’s college districts — Katy, close to Houston, and Belton, close to Waco — had adopted the supplies.
“I watched … fourth- and sixth-grade honor college students write a thanks word and was shocked by what I noticed—the shortage of legible handwriting and the horrific spelling,” she mentioned.
Districts on the fence about Bluebonnet can rethink their determination subsequent 12 months. To make it extra engaging, lawmakers added monetary incentives—as much as $60 per scholar for districts that use state-approved supplies. That was probably one purpose why the 27,000-student Lubbock colleges adopted it, mentioned Clinton Gill, a former math and science trainer within the district who now works for the Texas State Academics Affiliation.
On the similar time, he thinks district leaders assume college students will stand a greater likelihood of performing effectively on the state check if officers match it as much as a curriculum the state developed. Adopting Bluebonnet “additionally helps the district not have to rent workers to write down curriculum after they get it from the state at no cost.”
The per-student bonus isn’t the one method the state goals to make sure Bluebonnet turns into the popular selection. In December, the month after the board authorised it, the Texas Schooling Company shortly made Bluebonnet out there to order. Supplies from different publishers weren’t out there till Might.
“Plainly Bluebonnet Studying had a bonus,” Little informed Morath, the commissioner, throughout a June assembly. She mentioned she heard complaints from publishers over the difficulty.
Morath referred to as the delay a “one-time exacerbated drawback” as a result of the state had so as to add new language to contracts with publishers earlier than making their supplies out there to districts. Whereas the time lapse must be shorter subsequent 12 months, he mentioned there would at all times be some hole.
Within the present state price range, lawmakers licensed Morath to contract with companies to “promote, market, and promote” Bluebonnet. A separate appropriations invoice offers $243 million to districts to assist with implementation prices, like teaching for academics.
Final 12 months’s price range included $10 million for regional training service facilities to do comparable work for districts adopting Bluebonnet. The facilities are anticipated to meet targets for rising the variety of districts utilizing the supplies of their area to remain eligible for future funding.
Some leaders within the state say that top-down stress may alter the connection the facilities have historically had with college programs of their areas. They assist districts, particularly smaller ones with fewer central workplace workers, keep in compliance with state rules or work on college enchancment.
The service facilities have at all times been a “hub of data,” mentioned Martha Salazar-Zamora, superintendent of the Tomball Unbiased College District, north of Houston. Anticipating districts to promote Bluebonnet, she mentioned, “has been extra of a strategic push.”
She doesn’t doubt that Bluebonnet will enhance studying scores for some college students, however Tomball is already rated a high-performing district within the state’s accountability system. One more reason why she didn’t think about this system is {that a} Spanish model is just not but out there. Her district, the place about 35% of scholars are English learners, has a Spanish-English twin language program.
“I really like something that helps youngsters,” she mentioned. “I simply don’t suppose it’s the fitting software for each district.”
This story was produced by The 74 and reviewed and distributed by Stacker.
RELATED CONTENT: Winsome Earle-Sears Focused By Racist Signal, Virginia Leaders Condemn Incident
