October 8, 2025
The choice marks the top of Gilbert-Daniels’s journey to show copyright infringement.
P-Valley author and producer, Katori Corridor, is breaking her silence after the U.S. Supreme Courtroom refused to listen to her copyright infringement case introduced by Dr. Nicole “Nicci” Gilbert-Daniels.
This closes the years-long authorized battle over claims that Corridor’s hit collection P-Valley copied Gilbert-Daniels’s authentic work. Gilbert-Daniels took her case to the Supreme Courtroom in April 2025. She argued that decrease courts didn’t correctly assess the “qualitative worth” of artistic expression in works centering on Black ladies’s tales. The excessive court docket declined to hear the attraction, Docket 24-1251, with out remark.
In response to the Supreme Courtroom’s choice, P-Valley creator Corridor launched a press release on Instagram. Corridor has mentioned little or no since Gilbert-Daniels’s preliminary submitting. She is now detailing the “weak” methods she bared her “artistic course of” in an try to confirm the originality of P-Valley.
“I disclosed that e mail together with over 16,000 pages–varied drafts of the play, tv pitches and coverings, and even an early pilot of P-VALLEY–all proof of my impartial creation,” Corridor wrote.
Corridor asserts the ordeal has left her bruised each personally and professionally. But, she holds no ailing will towards Gilbert-Daniels.
“Whereas this lengthy and arduous ordeal has examined my repute and my persistence, I want the plaintiff peace. I’m so grateful the reality has prevailed, permitting me to lastly shut this tough chapter.”
Moreover, Gilbert-Daniels posted a press release on Instagram. The producer asserted that the rejection was as a result of a damaged system that favored highly effective Hollywood studios.
“By declining to listen to this case, the Courtroom missed an opportunity to handle a troubling sample: the near-automatic dismissal of artistic plaintiffs’ claims earlier than a jury ever hears them. Hollywood has received 99% of copyright instances over the previous twenty years, not as a result of each artist was mistaken, however as a result of the system is constructed to favor the highly effective.”
Gilbert-Daniels, a singer-songwriter and tv producer identified for her work with the R&B group Brownstone, filed swimsuit in 2021. The singer alleged that the hit present drew closely from her stage play and 2011 movie Soul Kittens Cabaret. Each tasks explored the lives of ladies navigating efficiency and survival in a nightlife setting. She argued that creator Katori Corridor and Lionsgate used “substantial parts” of her idea with out credit score or compensation.
Federal courts repeatedly rejected Gilbert-Daniels’s claims. In December 2023, U.S. District Choose Percy Anderson dominated that the 2 works overlap and amounted to “unprotectable concepts and inventory parts.” The choose concluded that no affordable jury might discover copyright infringement underneath U.S. legislation. The Ninth Circuit upheld that call in early 2024.
The denial marks the top of Gilbert-Daniels’ attraction choices and leaves intact lower-court rulings that discovered P-Valley didn’t infringe on her mental property. The Starz collection, which premiered in 2020, stays one of many community’s most critically acclaimed exhibits and was renewed for a 3rd season in October 2022.
RELATED CONTENT: Photographs Fired! R&;B Diva Nicci Gilbert Says ;P-Valley’; Author Ripped Off Her 2010 Stage Play
