That is the second a part of the republication of my evaluation of Lord Alan Milburn’s report for the federal government on younger individuals Not in Employment, Schooling or Coaching (NEETs) issued in Could 2026.
On this publish, I argue that, based mostly on information evaluation, the federal government is misconstruing the employment drawback for younger individuals.
The publication this week of Alan Milburn’s interim report on younger individuals and work has generated the standard wave of obvious alarm in our media in response to the declare that there are almost a million younger individuals not in schooling, employment or coaching (NEET) at current.
This, it’s stated, creates a subsequent technology which is in danger. It’s claimed that it is a nationwide disaster. And the federal government, we’re being instructed, should act now.
I’ve heard all that, however I’ve to say my quick, instinctive response to the claims was that none of them made a lot sense, no less than in a historic context the place what’s being claimed to be distinctive truly seems to be regular and unexceptional.
Because of this, I’ve been working by way of the underlying information on this subject, increase an image from first ideas. And whereas I don’t, in any manner, wish to minimise the actual difficulties dealing with many younger individuals, I feel the NEET framing that Labour seems to have chosen to focus upon misleads greater than it illuminates. The numbers, if learn correctly, do, for my part, inform a somewhat completely different story that factors to the necessity to deal with a fairly completely different set of coverage priorities. The true query is just not, then, simply why there’s a NEET drawback, however why is that this the actual subject Labour is selecting to focus on when there could be larger ones requiring consideration?
Let me clarify what I did and what I discovered.
What I did and the way
The place to begin for what I’ve accomplished was Milburn’s report, which accommodates a chart (its Determine 1) exhibiting the UK NEET charge for 16 to 24-year-olds from 2001 to 2025, drawn from the Labour Drive Survey. I extracted the important thing information factors cited within the textual content and reconstructed the annual sequence.
Chart 1: UK NEET charge, 16–24 yr olds, 2000–2025

The very first thing that struck me was how persistent this NEET charge has been at or about present ranges, though it peaked within the aftermath of the monetary disaster at 16.9% in 2012. Then the pandemic produced a deceptive dip as a result of furlough artificially suppressed unemployment, and never as a result of extra younger individuals had been in work or studying. However except for these two distortions, the speed has moved inside a remarkably slender band. For many of the previous twenty-five years, it has sat between 11% and 13%. Right now it’s at round 12.8% if Workplace for Nationwide Statistics information on this subject is true, which, even they admit, is an enormous assumption to make, given how unreliable their employment information has been in recent times. We don’t, then, have a present disaster in any significant sense of that phrase. Neither is there any important upward pattern on this information that may be meaningfully extrapolated from current very short-run variations, though that’s what reviews are suggesting. The present NEET charge is, in actual fact, near the long-run norm.
The inhabitants behind the speed
My curiosity, nonetheless, was not happy by discovering this. To grasp what the NEET charge truly means when it comes to individuals, you might want to know what number of 16 to 24-year-olds there are. So the subsequent step was to plot the scale of that cohort to assist perceive developments inside it.
Chart 2: UK inhabitants aged 16–24, 2000–2025

The cohort peaked in 2012, the identical yr the NEET charge peaked. The 2 occasions are, after all, associated. Excessive ranges of younger individuals within the inhabitants inevitably result in a excessive NEET charge. Any coverage will at all times affect this group first if they’re disproportionately massive within the inhabitants as a complete.
Since then, the quantity on this group has fallen after which partially risen once more, however to not its former excessive ranges.
Going again to births
To grasp this, I went again to the UK stay births sequence, which runs from 1976.
Chart 3: UK births 1976 to 2025

The sample right here is hanging. The child increase of the late Nineteen Eighties and early Nineties fed by way of into a big 16 to 24-year-old cohort within the 2000s and early 2010s, giving rise to the 2012 peak seen in earlier charts. A second surge in births through the mid-2000s by way of to 2012 produced the cohort that’s now working its manner by way of the 16 to 24 bracket and can proceed to take action till the late 2020s. After 2012, births fell sharply and have continued falling. The provisional 2025 determine, at round 662,000 for the UK, is the bottom since information started in 1976. The overall fertility charge in England and Wales has fallen to 1.39 — a document low, and nicely beneath the two.1 alternative stage.
Predicting the 16 to 24-year-old inhabitants from births
As a result of the connection between births and the 16 to 24 age group is mechanically easy, since you simply sum the beginning cohorts from sixteen to twenty-four years earlier, the beginning information provides us a near-certain forecast of how massive the youth cohort might be within the coming years. Assuming no deaths (which is an affordable approximation for this age group, the place mortality charges are low) we get this chart, wherein I comapre forecast and precise information plus NEET developments, utilizing a proper hand axis for NEET information.
Chart 4: Predicted 16–24 inhabitants from births (+ 1m migration) vs ONS precise, 2000–2025

The forecast and precise information monitor one another nicely. The precise information carefully predicts the NEET charge in precise quantity phrases.
The constant migration impact ought to be famous: over the entire interval, there are round 1 million extra younger individuals than births predicted. They got here to the UK as youngsters or younger individuals. There isn’t a broad change in that determine over the entire interval.
This then let me forecast, utilizing the birth-based prediction plus the a million uplift developments in inhabitants in coming years, plus doubtless NEET charges. This chart of the 16 to 24 inhabitants and the NEET rely, each precise to 2025 and forecast to 2035, provides us the clearest view of the place we’re heading.
Chart 5: 16–24 inhabitants and NEET rely, precise 2000–2025, forecast 2026–2035

The forecast is constructed on a easy and clear assumption: that the NEET charge stays flat at its present stage of round 13%, which can be a constant information level all through the interval checked out. Apply that to the projected inhabitants, and also you get the forecast NEET rely.
What does this information present?
The forecast reveals that the variety of NEETs will rise for a number of extra years, however not as a result of the speed or subject is worsening, however as a result of the cohort is rising because the bigger beginning years of 2008 to 2014 transfer by way of the 16 to 24 window. However the rise is modest, and it goes into reverse from round 2030 as these cohorts age out and are changed by the a lot smaller beginning cohorts of the early 2020s. By the mid-2030s the 16 to 24 inhabitants might be falling, and with it, at a continuing charge, absolutely the variety of NEETs.
So is there actually a disaster?
Let me be clear about what this evaluation does and doesn’t present.
It doesn’t present that the scenario dealing with younger individuals in Britain is snug or acceptable. A NEET charge of 12 to 13%, that means one in eight younger persons are exterior schooling, employment and coaching, is just not one thing to be relaxed about.
The Milburn report is true that too a lot of these younger persons are experiencing well being-related inactivity, that the system fails them, and that the structural issues are actual, though, as I’ve famous this morning, it doesn’t level out that UK youth unemployment can be a deliberate function of UK financial coverage that the Financial institution of England is tasked with delivering.
However the framing of an escalating disaster in NEET numbers doesn’t face up to shut demographic scrutiny. The speed is just not rising considerably. Absolutely the numbers will rise for a number of years just because the cohort is rising, however that may be a mechanical demographic impact, not a coverage failure. And by the 2030s, because the low-birth cohorts of the early 2020s come of age, the numbers will fall again no matter what coverage does.
If we’re on the lookout for a real, structural, worsening drawback for younger individuals in Britain, I might counsel that this information reveals that we’re wanting within the incorrect place.
The true subject: insecurity inside work
The NEET measure captures solely these exterior schooling, employment and coaching. It says nothing concerning the high quality of the employment that younger individuals do handle to seek out. And right here the image is genuinely alarming.
Younger employees in Britain are disproportionately concentrated within the sectors and contracts that supply the least safety: zero-hours preparations, gig financial system platforms, short-term company work, part-time roles that can’t maintain unbiased residing.
On the similar time, the collapse in apprenticeship begins, that are down by greater than 40% in line with the Milburn report, means fewer younger persons are coming into structured, skill-building employment of the sort that traditionally supplied a ladder.
The normal Saturday job in retail and hospitality that supplied work expertise has additionally largely disappeared, and lots of entry-level roles have been automated or made conditional on expertise that a teenager can not by definition have already got.
Because the Milburn report notes, it’s hanging that just about 30% of NEETs have good GCSEs or increased {qualifications}. The difficulty is that the labour market is failing to soak up them, and never that they lack credentials. It’s not their fault that the construction of the employment market has modified. Good {qualifications} now provide much less safety in opposition to insecure, low-wage, zero-hours work than they as soon as did.
What we face, in different phrases, is just not primarily a NEET disaster. We face a youth employment high quality disaster. We face a scenario the place being nominally in employment gives far much less safety, revenue, talent growth and development than it as soon as did. That isn’t captured within the NEET statistics in any respect. An adolescent on a zero-hours contract in a warehouse, incomes too little to afford their very own residence and with no prospect of development, is counted as employed. They don’t seem within the NEET numbers. However their scenario is arguably worse by being extra invisible, and concurrently extra structurally entrenched, than somebody who’s NEET and no less than seen to the help system.
What the federal government ought to actually be asking
The Milburn evaluation is just not incorrect to doc the failure of well being providers, welfare programs and schooling pathways to help younger individuals into participation. These failures are actual and documented. However by framing the whole train across the NEET measure, there’s a danger that the coverage response focuses on transferring younger individuals off the NEET rely somewhat than bettering the precise high quality of their lives, and each matter.
The questions that deserve extra urgency are these:
- Why has the youth share of the labour market declined at the same time as total employment elevated?
- Why have apprenticeship begins collapsed?
- Why are so many entry-level roles now accessed by way of automated recruitment programs that display screen out inexperienced younger employees earlier than any human has checked out them?
- Why has the housing market made monetary independence not possible for many younger employees in high-demand areas?
- And why are the types of employment most obtainable to younger individuals, equivalent to gig work, zero-hours contracts, and company work, exactly people who provide the least safety, the least talent growth and the least pathway to safety?
These are questions concerning the construction of the labour market itself. They require solutions that go nicely past the welfare, well being and schooling reforms that Milburn’s analysis, nonetheless correct, tends to counsel.
They require serious about:
- labour market regulation,
- employer incentives,
- the position of commerce unions in sectors the place younger individuals truly work, and
- the connection between housing prices and the viability of low-wage employment.
The NEET numbers will largely handle themselves because the demography shifts, as I present. In that case, to deal with this subject alone is a distraction. The insecurity that younger employees face inside employment is not going to be going away anytime quickly, and it’s on that subject that focus is basically required.
Methodology
This evaluation was produced utilizing publicly obtainable information from the Workplace for Nationwide Statistics, the Labour Drive Survey, and the Milburn interim report on Younger Individuals and Work (Could 2026).
The charts described on this piece had been produced from ONS important statistics, mid-year inhabitants estimates and Labour Drive Survey NEET information. All projections use identified beginning cohort information to 2025 with post-2025 births held on the 2025 provisional determine of roughly 662,000, plus a a million migration uplift utilized to mirror the constant immigration impact noticed within the 16–24 ONS inhabitants sequence. The NEET forecast applies a flat 13% charge — roughly the present stage — to the projected inhabitants. No mortality adjustment is made, as little one and younger grownup mortality charges within the UK are sufficiently low that their exclusion doesn’t materially have an effect on the projection.
Claude AI was used ot help information presentation used right here.
Thanks for studying this publish.
You’ll be able to share this publish on social media of your alternative by clicking these icons:
There are hyperlinks to this weblog’s glossary within the above publish that designate technical phrases utilized in it. Observe them for extra explanations.
You’ll be able to subscribe to this weblog’s each day e-mail right here.
And if you want to help this weblog you possibly can, right here: