Monday, November 16, 2026
HomeTaxPortland Honest Share Tax: Particulars & Evaluation

Portland Honest Share Tax: Particulars & Evaluation


Beneath the Honest Share Tax, a proposal pending earlier than Portland Metropolis Council, some firms may quickly face a 26.2 p.c state and native revenue taxA tax is a compulsory fee or cost collected by native, state, and nationwide governments from people or companies to cowl the prices of normal authorities companies, items, and actions. price, plus a 1.57 p.c gross receipts taxGross receipts taxes are utilized to an organization’s product sales, with out deductions for a agency’s enterprise bills, like compensation, prices of products bought, and overhead prices. In contrast to a gross sales tax, a gross receipts tax is assessed on companies and applies to transactions at each stage of the manufacturing course of, resulting in tax pyramiding. price (not accounting for a partial deduction for the price of labor or price of products bought, which can differ by enterprise). For a enterprise with a 7 p.c revenue margin, that represents a 48.6 p.c price on web revenue simply from state and native revenue and gross receipts taxes, earlier than even contemplating federal taxes or native property taxes. However one of many proposal’s co-sponsors, Metropolis Councilor Mitch Inexperienced (D-District 4), argues the proposed tax shouldn’t be a priority as a result of, he contends, Portland’s present enterprise taxes aren’t really excessive.

He’s mistaken.

The Councilor’s proposal would add a multiplier to the prevailing metropolis enterprise license (revenue) tax with charges based mostly on CEO compensation ratios, with the best price set at 15.6 p.c—greater than the best state company revenue taxA company revenue tax (CIT) is levied by federal and state governments on enterprise earnings. Many firms usually are not topic to the CIT as a result of they’re taxed as pass-through companies, with revenue reportable underneath the person revenue tax. of 11.5 p.c in New Jersey. This could be along with Oregon’s 7.6 p.c high state company revenue tax price, a 2 p.c county tax, a 1 p.c regional tax, and each metropolis and state gross receipts taxes.

Councilor Inexperienced contends that Portland’s present enterprise tax burdens are cheap and particularly objects to our prior evaluation, which finds that Portland has among the highest enterprise taxes within the nation. However can his declare be true? Is it doable that, as his workplace purports to point out, Portland’s enterprise taxes are virtually 40 p.c decrease than Pittsburgh’s and barely 1 / 4 of Seattle’s?

The reply is, after all, no: Portland is a uniquely high-tax jurisdiction, and the calculations the Councilor depends on are deeply flawed. The outcomes increase apparent crimson flags, akin to the truth that the calculations for Seattle yield a 142 p.c efficient tax price for a typical enterprise from gross sales, payroll, and gross receipts taxes alone. Even with out contemplating federal revenue taxes, native property taxes, or another taxes, Councilor Inexperienced’s comparative tables present a Seattle enterprise paying the whole thing of its earnings, after which 42 p.c extra, in state and native taxes. Seattle’s taxes are excessive, however they aren’t that excessive.

It’s value understanding how these calculations went awry, as a result of correcting the errors yields exactly the conclusion that the so-called Honest Share Tax’s sponsor makes an attempt to disprove: Portland’s enterprise taxes are already uniquely excessive.

Each Portland and the state of Oregon have gross receipts taxes, that are main drivers of the area’s excessive enterprise tax burdens, although a constellation of state, regional, county, and metropolis revenue taxes additionally contribute considerably to the general tax invoice. Oregon doesn’t, nonetheless, levy a gross sales taxA gross sales tax is levied on retail gross sales of products and companies and, ideally, ought to apply to all ultimate consumption with few exemptions. Many governments exempt items like groceries; base broadening, akin to together with groceries, may preserve charges decrease. A gross sales tax ought to exempt business-to-business transactions which, when taxed, trigger tax pyramiding. —one in every of 5 states to forgo one. The Councilor’s evaluation makes an attempt an “apples-to-apples” comparability by changing different jurisdictions’ taxes into gross receipts tax equivalents, however errs in a number of respects, nowhere extra considerably than within the conversion of normal gross sales taxes into gross receipts tax equivalents.

The Councilor’s FAQ acknowledges that gross sales tax calculations drive the outcomes however fails to acknowledge that the calculations are gravely in error. After a desk evaluating Portland to a number of different jurisdictions, the textual content reads: “Discover that Portland’s varied tax charges sum to a pretty big quantity, slightly below Seattle’s. However after changing to the equal tax on gross receipts, these charges develop into very small. Certainly, as a result of Oregon and the jurisdictions therein don’t have a gross sales tax, the precise tax burden is far decrease than different cities.”

It isn’t. The conversion is mistaken.

In Seattle, for example, gross sales taxes are estimated to price companies 5.93 p.c of gross income, which is nearly 85 p.c of the revenue of a enterprise with 7 p.c revenue margins. Seattle’s gross sales taxes alone are estimated to impose as a lot as 243 p.c of the entire enterprise tax burden calculated for Portland (2.44 to 2.54 p.c of gross income), which is clearly mistaken.

The Councilor’s evaluation converts gross sales tax charges into gross receipts equivalents by dividing the overall gross sales tax price by 1.78 p.c, based mostly on a misinterpretation of a paper that estimates 1.78 because the ratio of gross receipts to ultimate consumption. The paper’s estimate is completely cheap and is actually equivalent to the ratio of US gross output to GDP. It’s a ratio of all transactions to consumption and has nothing to do with gross sales taxes.

Complete consumption shouldn’t be the identical as taxable gross sales. It consists of transactions largely excluded from gross sales tax bases (like healthcare, insurance coverage, groceries, and authorized companies), and it even consists of consumption that doesn’t contain a transaction, just like the imputed worth of residing in a single’s own residence. And whereas some business-to-business transactions are taxed, and their prices are a minimum of partially borne by companies, it’s additionally clearly mistaken to use all the price of gross sales taxes—a shopper tax—to companies.

The magnitude of this error could be demonstrated by making use of the Councilor’s methodology to gross sales taxes nationwide. That yields $2.37 trillion in enterprise gross sales tax burdens in FY 2024, whereas whole state and native gross sales tax collections have been about $588 billion, together with each shopper and enterprise purchases.

To place this in additional context, EY and the Council on State Taxation estimate that companies paid about $245 billion that 12 months, one-tenth of what Councilor Inexperienced’s methodology suggests. Federal company revenue tax collections have been $472 billion in FY 2024, making the Councilor’s estimates of companies’ share of state and native gross sales tax burdens 5 instances what the federal authorities collects in company revenue tax income.

In different phrases, the first cause Portland’s taxes look modest in contrast with different jurisdictions is that the evaluation takes the one main tax Oregon lacks and overstates its burdens by an element of ten.

The comparability additionally accommodates different errors and omissions. It applies Seattle’s Social Housing Tax, which applies solely to compensation above $1 million per worker, and its JumpStart Housing Tax, which applies solely to bigger companies, to all wages. It lists Pennsylvania’s company revenue tax however drops it from Pittsburgh’s whole tax calculation, omits California’s company revenue tax completely, excludes Oregon’s TriMet employer payroll taxA payroll tax is a tax paid on the wages and salaries of staff to finance social insurance coverage packages like Social Safety, Medicare, and unemployment insurance coverage. Payroll taxes are social insurance coverage taxes that comprise 24.8 p.c of mixed federal, state, and native authorities income, the second largest supply of that mixed tax income., applies Portland’s Clear Vitality Surcharge to all companies, and disregards deductions underneath the Oregon CAT. These errors reduce each methods, however they point out a haphazard strategy. Property taxes (on actual property in addition to equipment and gear), which characterize about 34 p.c of all state and native taxes paid by companies, are additionally omitted, although this omission is acknowledged.

The Councilor’s personal evaluation yields a 36.3 p.c efficient price on a enterprise with 7 p.c revenue margins from state and native enterprise revenue and gross receipts taxes alone, even earlier than the brand new tax, which is astonishingly excessive. It’s too excessive, in actual fact, as a result of a number of calculation errors. However the actuality is that Portland’s taxes are very excessive, and the Councilor’s evaluation does nothing to contradict that. It merely compares it favorably to vastly inflated charges in different jurisdictions.

These usually are not simply calculation errors. In addition they circulation by into the broader evaluation.

The Councilor’s FAQ argues, for example, that low-margin companies like grocery retailer chains will have the ability to deal with an elevated tax burden in Portland because the enhance is supposedly minuscule in comparison with “the precise gross sales taxes in Vancouver, Washington, the place there are many grocery shops regardless of state and native taxes 45 instances greater than this ordinance proposes.” Not solely does this depend on the beforehand talked about miscalculation of gross sales tax burdens, changing an 8.9 p.c gross sales tax right into a 5 p.c tax on grocers’ gross receipts—an unattainable 250 p.c efficient price from gross sales tax alone, based mostly on the Councilor’s appropriate identification of grocery retailer revenue margins as about 2 p.c—however it misses the truth that Washington, like most states, exempts groceries from the gross sales tax.

Portland already has anomalously excessive enterprise taxes, and the proposed tax would make these charges astronomical. Enterprise taxes imposed based mostly on gross sales right into a jurisdiction are inclined to present up in costs, which means Portland shoppers would bear a considerable share of the elevated tax burden, even when massive firms are those to remit the tax. Some companies might discover that they will now not afford to function in Portland in any respect, decreasing shopper selection and undercutting native employment.

As Portland Metropolis Council considers the proposed tax enhance, they need to perceive town’s place to begin—as arguably the highest-tax jurisdiction in the whole nation—not one of many lowest.

Keep knowledgeable on the tax insurance policies impacting you.

Subscribe to our free publication to get the newest tax information, information and evaluation.

Subscribe

Share this text








RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments