Monday, November 16, 2026
HomeBitcoinThe Token Identification Disaster - Bitfinex weblog

The Token Identification Disaster – Bitfinex weblog


For greater than a decade, the crypto trade has been constructing elaborate workarounds for a easy downside: tokens aren’t shares. They’ll govern a protocol, unlock a reduction, sign membership in a group however they can’t, in most jurisdictions, entitle the holder to a dividend, a vote on the board, or a declare if the corporate goes bust. 

Now three firms are attempting to break down that hole, every from a unique course, and in doing so, they’re forcing an uncomfortable query again to the floor: if firm possession can dwell on a blockchain, what are crypto tokens really for?

The conversion

Essentially the most dramatic transfer landed on 17 August, when Bhaji Illuminati — chief govt of Centrifuge Labs and a board member of the Centrifuge Community Basis — posted CP172 to the challenge’s governance discussion board. Centrifuge, among the many earliest tokenisation platforms with greater than $2 billion in real-world belongings tokenised to this point, requested its group to think about changing its CFG governance token into fairness.

The mechanics, if accredited, would see the non-profit basis behind Centrifuge re-registered as a Cayman Islands exempted firm. Each CFG holder can be supplied a voluntary swap: one share for every token transferred. Holders of 100,000 CFG or extra would enter the share register instantly; smaller holders would take part via an meant association with CoinList.

The proposal is framed as a query and sits on the request-for-comment stage, with a 14-day suggestions window, which ends 1 September, and a tokenholder vote promised however not but scheduled. Centrifuge causes that the token construction is obstructing institutional capital. And now, shifting regulatory attitudes give tokenholders a reputable path to changing into precise shareholders.

The group response has been pointed. Inside days, roughly 37 posts appeared on the discussion board thread, with recurring calls for for an unbiased valuation behind the one-for-one conversion ratio, a totally diluted cap desk, outlined shareholder rights, a liquidity plan for the ensuing shares, readability on KYC and jurisdictional eligibility, and what occurs to unconverted CFG. A group based within the heyday of decentralisation is now haggling over the phrases of a company restructuring.

The promise

Backpack, the trade and pockets enterprise based in 2022 by Solana developer Armani Ferrante, is navigating the identical boundary from the alternative facet, by promising tokenholders future possession.

The BP token launched on 23 March, 2026 with a complete provide of 1 billion. Notably, founders, workers and enterprise buyers obtained no token allocations — they maintain firm fairness as an alternative. Prospects who stake BP for no less than one yr earn the precise to trade these tokens for fairness if Backpack reaches an IPO, acquisition or comparable exit.

Apparently, if each eligible token have been staked for the complete interval, individuals would collectively attain 20 p.c of firm fairness — 12.5 p.c base plus a 7.5 p.c bonus. A token that converts into shares sits near the definition of a safety beneath most frameworks, however Backpack’s structure reads as a deliberate effort to maintain BP itself on the precise facet of that line. Whether or not regulators learn it the identical method is untested.

Both method, it’s a transparent instance of crypto founders aligning their incentives with tokenholders. On this case, Backpack founders will drive worth to enterprise fairness however nonetheless give tokenholders a proper to take part within the success of the protocol, deftly managing the fantastic line between a standard definition of a safety and their experimental course of.

The register

Determine has taken probably the most radical strategy of the three: meting out with the token totally.

Listed on Nasdaq beneath FIGR since September 2025, Determine introduced the On-Chain Public Fairness Community (OPEN) in January 2026 — a system that lets firms challenge fairness natively on the Provenance Blockchain. Precise shares, registered on-chain.

Determine grew to become OPEN’s first issuer on 19 February, launching FGRS, which it says is the primary SEC-registered public fairness issued and settled natively on blockchain infrastructure. FGRS is a definite sequence, Sequence A Blockchain Frequent Inventory, that ranks equally with Determine’s Nasdaq-listed Class A shares for dividends and liquidation, carries one vote per share, and converts one-for-one into Class A inventory on the holder’s election. 

The providing is emblematic of the kind of regulatory gymnastics that blockchain firms carry out to stay on the precise facet of legislators, typically leaving retail merchandise additional down the road. For Determine, buying and selling can occur across the clock, however solely on Determine’s SEC-registered various buying and selling system. So it could’t entry the advantages of being on a nationwide securities trade, or public blockchain.

Nonetheless, the system does retain among the advantages pioneered by crypto protocols equivalent to settlement in YLDS, Determine’s SEC-registered yield-bearing stablecoin. And shareholders can borrow towards or lend out their inventory via Democratized Prime, Determine’s on-chain lending market. 

Three solutions, one query

Tokenisation began by placing conventional belongings — loans, fund items, treasuries — on blockchains so they might settle sooner, commerce past market hours and plug into on-chain lending. Wrappers round issues that existed elsewhere. Now, the underlying asset is possession of the corporate itself, and the blockchain is the register.

It’s not right here but. Centrifuge’s group might reshape or reject CP172 totally. Backpack’s fairness rights are conditional, non-voting and untested towards an actual exit. Determine’s market operates inside a permissioned setting whose liquidity depth stays unproven.

However collectively they define a solution to the query of how crypto initiatives ought to deal with worth accrual whereas retaining decentralisation. Up till now, the hyperlink between a challenge’s success and their token’s price has virtually all the time been implicit — a matter of narrative and community results reasonably than enforceable rights.

However growing regulatory readability, equivalent to this week’s crypto rule proposals from the SEC, permits options. These three initiatives are a part of a dialog between crypto customers, founders, and regulators in the direction of creating the readability of fairness possession onchain.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments